In this guide
If you're lying awake listening to your new puppy cry in the crate, wondering whether you've made a terrible mistake, take a breath. Crying in the first nights is common, expected and usually temporary. Once you know why it happens, it stops feeling like a verdict on you or your puppy.
Why puppies cry in the crate
Think about your puppy's week. Everything is new: the home, the smells, the people, the crate, and often being alone at night. Crying is the only way they have to say something about it.
Puppies want their people at night. In one study of 16-week-old puppies who could reach their owners at night, 86.7% chose to sleep near them (Kinsman 2020). A puppy crying in a crate at the far end of the house is often simply asking where everyone went.
There's also a practical reason. Dogs tend to avoid going to the toilet where they sleep. A young puppy with a small bladder who wakes up needing to go can't fix that alone. Crying is how they ask you to help keep their bed clean.
And sometimes the crying is about something else entirely: a crate introduced too quickly, a puppy who is frightened, or a puppy who is uncomfortable or unwell. Those cries need a very different answer, which is why it pays to tell them apart (more on that below).
What's normal in the first nights
Here's the honest picture, so you can measure your nights against reality and not against a "crate-trained in a weekend" promise.
The best data we have comes from one small study of 60 puppies aged 6 to 10 weeks (Taylor & Mills 2007). More than 70% of the puppies who slept alone disturbed the household on their first night. On average there were about 5 to 6 disturbed nights over 2 months, and most of them came in the first week. Puppies who slept alongside another dog disturbed almost no one (alongside, not in the same crate: see the safety basics below).
That's one study of 60 puppies, published in 2007. It's useful as a rough guide to what's typical, not a promise about your puppy. Yours may settle faster, or take longer. If your first week is loud, you're in good company.
| When | What's typical |
|---|---|
| First night | Crying is the norm, not the exception. Most puppies sleeping alone wake the house at least once. |
| First week | The loudest stretch. Most of the disturbed nights happen here. |
| Under ~4 months | One or two night potty breaks are normal. A crying puppy at 2 am may genuinely need to go. |
| 16–20 weeks | Most puppies start sleeping through without a toilet break. Some still need a night trip until about 5 months. |
| Crate training overall | Puppies who'd seen a crate before often need 1–3 weeks of consistent practice. Brand-new or previously scared dogs take longer. |
During the day, the same rule applies: brief vocalizing, pawing or fidgeting when a puppy first goes in is normal, and many settle within a few minutes. When the noise starts matters, too. Crying within minutes of going in suggests stress. Crying after a puppy has settled is more often boredom, hunger or a toilet need.
The 4 kinds of cry, and what each one means
Most advice gives you one rule for every cry: "always go to them" or "always ignore it". Both go wrong, because cries aren't all the same. A puppy who needs to pee and a puppy who wants out to play can sound alike to a tired owner at 3 am. We group them into four kinds: Potty, Protest, Panic and Pain.
Panic and Pain matter most, because they're about safety. If you see their signs, the crate can wait. The "When to see a vet" section below lists what to look out for.
Now you know why. Here's the fix.
A calm, night-by-night plan for quieter nights and a dog who walks into the crate on their own. What to do about each cry, and what to change when it isn't working.
- The Cry Code: Potty, Protest, Panic or Pain, and what to do about each
- 14 real-life situations, from 3 am wake-ups to rescues
- 10 printables, including the Night Log and Door Ladder Chart
- Instant PDF · 30-day money-back guarantee
More than one puppy problem? The First 8 Weeks Bundle (coming soon) will include all 3 Fix guides plus the New Puppy Playbook for $29, instead of $55 separately.
4 myths that make crate crying worse
The AKC says never to leave a dog to "cry it out", and UK veterinary charity PDSA says not to ignore crying, especially in the first few nights. Some older guidance does say to ignore whining, so sources disagree, and no study has compared ignoring with responding. We take the welfare-first side. A puppy left to cry may genuinely need to go, and then has no choice but to soil the bed they're trying to keep clean. A puppy in real distress isn't learning anything, either.
A partial cover can help some nervous dogs feel more tucked away, and it can help during fireworks. But it doesn't answer whatever the crying is about. A cover changes the view, not the need to pee or the wish to be near you. If you do cover a wire crate, leave one or two sides open, and don't cover it at all if your dog pulls the fabric in through the bars.
Used well, a crate keeps a puppy safe when no one can watch them, helps with house-training, and prepares them for travel, vet stays and emergencies. Many dogs choose to rest in theirs, and many like a den-like space. The concern is real, though, when a crate is overused. Long stretches of confinement aren't healthy, no dog should live in a crate most of the time, and crating a dog all day while you're at work is never acceptable. Sweden strictly limits keeping dogs in crates, and the ethics of crating has been debated in the veterinary literature. Not every dog suits a crate, and for some a pen or gated room is the kinder answer.
Not while you're house-training. A crate that's too big leaves room for a separate "toilet end", which works against your puppy's natural wish to keep their bed clean. The right size lets your dog stand without ducking their head, turn around, and lie down stretched out. For a growing puppy, the usual advice is to buy for adult size and block off the extra space with a divider. Once a dog is house-trained, a larger crate is fine.
Crate safety basics
These aren't training steps. They're the safety rules every source agrees on, and they apply from the very first night.
A few more basics from the same sources: keep the crate out of direct sun, away from heaters and drafts, and make sure your dog always has access to fresh water. Don't let children poke fingers through the bars or tap on the sides.
Why crying can get worse, not better
When crying drags on for weeks, the cause is usually not the puppy. It's one of a few common patterns:
- One rule for every cry. Some nights we tough it out, other nights we cave and play. That teaches a puppy that noise sometimes works, so it's worth trying harder.
- Moving too fast. Whining during crate training usually means the time in the crate went up too quickly.
- The crate only means "you're leaving". If the door only ever closes right before you go out, the crate starts to predict being alone.
- Treating panic as attention-seeking. A frightened dog left shut in learns that the crate is a scary place.
When to see a vet or behaviorist
Most crate crying is normal and fades with time and good training. But some crying is a sign that the crate isn't right for this dog right now, or that something is wrong physically. Those cases won't improve with training alone.
- Heavy panting, drooling, frantic escape attempts, or persistent howling or barking in the crate
- Any injury to the mouth, teeth or nails from the crate
- Panic that keeps coming back, even when you've slowed right down
- A sudden yelp, or a sudden change from what's normal for your dog
- Unusual tiredness or lethargy, new restlessness at night, or changes in appetite or potty habits
- Snoring or gasping in flat-faced breeds
In the meantime, use a pen or a baby-gated room instead of the crate.
Is it separation anxiety? Crying that's really about being alone often comes with other signs: destruction near doors and windows, toilet accidents only when left alone, pacing, trembling, ignoring food or chews you leave, anxiety as you get ready to leave, and an over-the-top greeting when you come back. Filming your dog while you're out helps you tell anxiety from boredom.
A crate is not a treatment for separation anxiety. It may stop the damage, but it doesn't reduce the anxiety, and it can make it worse. Ask your vet to rule out medical causes first. For moderate or severe cases, look for a veterinary behaviorist (DACVB) or a Certified Applied Animal Behaviorist.
Ready for quieter nights?
The Crate Training Fix turns everything above into a plan you can start tonight: the first-night setup, the Cry Code, the Door Ladder and the Night-by-Night Plan.
- 112 pages, reward-based only
- No "cry it out", no bark collars, no spray bottles
- 10 printables, including the Cry Code Card
- Not helpful? Full refund within 30 days
Puppy also having accidents? Read why puppies keep peeing inside, or see The Potty Training Fix.
Get the free New Dog Checklist
Your first week on one checklist: supplies, vet questions and house rules.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy
Sources
- Taylor, K.D., Mills, D.S. A placebo-controlled study to investigate the effect of Dog Appeasing Pheromone and other environmental and management factors on the reports of disturbance and house soiling during the night in recently adopted puppies. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 2007;105:358–368. doi:10.1016/j.applanim.2006.11.003
- Kinsman, R., et al. Sleep duration and behaviours: a descriptive analysis of a cohort of dogs up to 12 months of age. Animals 2020;10:1172. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32664232/
- VCA Animal Hospitals (Lindell E, Feyrecilde M). Crate Training and Confinement for Puppies and Dogs.
- VCA Animal Hospitals (Horwitz D, Landsberg G). Separation Anxiety in Dogs.
- VCA Animal Hospitals. How Much Sleep Do Puppies Need?
- UC Davis Clinical Animal Behavior Service. Crate Training Your Puppy. 2009.
- Cornell Riney Canine Health Center (Cohen A). Dog crates: when to use them and how to pick one.
- Penn Vet Ryan Hospital, Behavior Medicine. Tips on Housetraining Your Dog.
- American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior (AVSAB). Position Statement on Humane Dog Training. 2021.
- ASPCA. Separation Anxiety.
- American Kennel Club (Gibeault S). How to Crate Train Your Dog in 9 Easy Steps.
- Humane World for Animals (formerly the Humane Society of the United States). Crate Training 101.
- Preventive Vet (Madson C). Everything you need to know about crate training your puppy or adult dog; Crate training your puppy at night; Setting up your dog's crate for comfort and safety.
- Best Friends Animal Society. How to crate train a puppy or dog.
- PDSA. Vet Q&A: Why do puppies cry at night? 2021.
- RSPCA. Dog crates.
- Dogs Trust. Playpen and crate training; Separation anxiety.
- Swedish Board of Agriculture. Regulation on the keeping of dogs and cats, SJVFS 2020:8.
- Fox, M.W. Questions ethics of crating (letter). JAVMA 2015;246:49. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25517322/
Written by the Dog Plus Me team from the sources above. Last updated November 2026. Spotted something that's out of date? Email hello@dogplusme.com.
Not veterinary advice. This guide is general education about training. It can't replace a check-up. If you're worried about your puppy's health or behavior, or something changes suddenly, please talk to your vet.